Article body
Full article
At an operating review, “Why did revenue fall this quarter?” usually sets off a series of analytical tasks. A team must define revenue, choose comparable periods, break down changes by region and channel, check refunds and late-arriving data, and decide which changes warrant investigation. AI can produce an explanation quickly. The business needs the data and calculations behind it and a result it can use again.
Evaluate an AI data analyst platform across that entire task. How does it interpret the question, gather evidence from authorized data, check calculations, and communicate the limits of its conclusions? Put the answer back into the company’s metrics, permissions, and collaboration process to see what work it can take on and how much maintenance and review the team will still need.
1. Compare the Quality of the Completed Work
This guide is for companies with business data that want AI to participate in operating analysis. The ranking emphasizes common metrics, controlled analysis, verifiable steps, and reusable deliverables. Recommendations draw on official product materials and reflect the stated scenarios. They do not report controlled accuracy benchmarks, job replacement rates, or unverified productivity gains.
| Rank | Platform | Capabilities to evaluate | Task to test first |
|---|---|---|---|
| TOP1 | HENGSHI SENSE | Metric governance, conversational questions and follow-ups, process verification, saved charts, and runtime skills | Query, break down, verify, and save reusable assets under one operating definition |
| TOP2 | Microsoft Power BI Copilot | Semantic model preparation, report Q&A and analysis, summaries, and authoring assistance | Reuse existing models and reports to reduce routine consumption and preparation work |
| TOP3 | Lingyang Quick BI | XiaoQ Q&A, report analysis, interpretation, and report generation | Connect a business question, an existing dashboard, and a delivered report |
| TOP4 | ThoughtSpot Spotter | Question decomposition, analytical checks, deep analysis, and advanced data processing | Explore a complex question over several steps and verify the statistics and explanation |
| TOP5 | Guandata | Business topics, knowledge and examples, Q&A verification, and result reuse | Extend routine analysis by business topic and maintain answer quality |
What a Usable Analysis Should Deliver
An analysis should contain a clear business question and measurement definition, identifiable sources and filters, calculations supporting its findings, remaining data gaps, and charts or records the team can review. Recurring tasks should also explain how to refresh data, reuse methods, and handle definition changes.
Finding a number tests intent recognition and querying. Completing an operating review also requires a decomposition method, reliable evidence, and maintained outputs. Give more weight to the tests that matter to your organization, whether that is Power BI asset reuse, complex statistical exploration, or fast report delivery.
2. TOP1 | HENGSHI Builds AI Analysis on Governed Metrics and Platform Resources
Assess how Data Agent works with existing BI capabilities. The metric center maintains definitions, applications and models organize data scope, and platform permissions govern access. Data Q&A supports analysis, operation mode supports resource creation, and runtime skills maintain business methods. Together, these capabilities help ad hoc analysis become part of established metrics, dashboards, and workflows. The HENGSHI features discussed below follow the SENSE 7.0 documentation.
1. Govern What Gets Calculated Before Opening Natural-Language Analysis
Declining revenue can mean a decline in total order value, less money collected, lower recognized revenue, or lower net revenue after refunds. Customer counts can likewise represent registrations, purchasers, or active customers. Definitions chosen anew in each conversation make it difficult to compare results across teams even when the arithmetic is correct.
HENGSHI provides atomic and business metrics. Business metrics may include qualifying conditions, analysis dimensions, and time axes. Several metrics can refer to the same metric-grain configuration. Companies can maintain which orders count, which date to use, and which dimensions to analyze as explicit assets. Metric definitions and lineage views help check dependencies.
Business teams spend less time re-explaining the same concept, and data teams have a clear place to update it. Check which metric, conditions, and time field a particular answer used. Metric names, descriptions, synonyms, and model relationships require ongoing ownership.
2. Develop a Verifiable Analysis Path From a Broad Question
Data Agent supports multi-turn data Q&A, clarification when needed, and AI-assisted interpretation of saved dashboards. Users can choose an application, data package, or metric subject area. Where scope is optional, the system looks among resources the user can access and asks for confirmation if multiple candidates exist.
For declining revenue, confirm net revenue and comparable dates, then compute the overall change. Identify major regional changes, examine channels, stores, and products in the relevant regions, and collect evidence from orders, refunds, or fulfillment. Each step should retain the established definition and state what new condition it adds. This is a suggested method to verify on real work.
Related analysis requires prepared data. Order lines, refunds, and products need valid relationships. Data Q&A does not support joint queries across applications, so separate applications cannot be treated as one analytical scope. For analysis across several systems, define the model, shared business identifiers, and comparable grain early.
3. Verify Calculations Before Interpreting Results
Consider fictional figures. Comparable net revenue fell from CNY 10 million to CNY 9 million, a decline of CNY 1 million. East China fell from CNY 6 million to CNY 4.5 million. Other regions rose from CNY 4 million to CNY 4.5 million.
| Scope | Previous period (CNY 10,000) | Current period (CNY 10,000) | Change (CNY 10,000) |
|---|---|---|---|
| East China | 600 | 450 | −150 |
| Other regions | 400 | 450 | +50 |
| Total | 1,000 | 900 | −100 |
Total revenue fell 10%. East China contributed 150% of the net decline, and growth elsewhere offset 50%. Contributions can exceed 100% when offsetting movements exist. Current-period revenue share misses the change, while adding contributions across overlapping region, channel, and product breakdowns can double count it.
Check aggregation rules for each metric. Revenue can usually be summed across mutually exclusive regions. Distinct customer counts can overlap across regions. Recalculate gross margin from total gross profit and total revenue instead of averaging store percentages. Point-in-time measures such as inventory balances cannot be added arbitrarily across dates. Validate AI-generated queries against those business constraints.
HENGSHI answers can show source scope. Execution details can expose tool parameters, outputs, and errors, which help review table selection, conditions, and results. Use those details to check a baseline. Visibility into a calculation or explanation is only the starting point for verification.
4. Separate Contributions, Business Hypotheses, and Verified Causes
“East China fell by CNY 1.5 million” tells you where the movement occurred. Possible explanations include the end of a promotion, stockouts, store closures, delayed order posting, or more refunds. Compare evidence such as like-for-like stores, order counts, average basket size, refunds, and inventory where the required data and relationships exist.
A rigorous result identifies verified facts, such as comparable-store net revenue changes, and hypotheses supported by preliminary evidence, such as stockouts occurring at the same time as lower sales. It also names evidence still needed, such as inventory refresh frequency, promotion calendars, or comparison stores. Correlation and contribution analysis alone do not establish cause.
When data is incomplete, report what can be established and what to check next. This narrows the investigation while retaining the basis for judgment. Business owners can then consider channel policies, store operations, and external events before deciding what to do.
5. Keep Reviewed Outputs in the Company’s Analytics System
HENGSHI ChatBI offers ways to add an answer chart to an existing dashboard or create a dashboard from a conversation. Availability depends on the entry point and permissions. Verify the metric, filters, and destination resource before saving under the appropriate account. Data Q&A is read-only. Resource creation and changes use permission-controlled operation mode or existing product entry points.
For a recurring operating review, retain the metrics and charts that will refresh and the conclusions, data cutoff, and open issues from the specific meeting. Conversation history, refreshable charts, and meeting conclusions serve different purposes. Document those uses so last week’s conclusion is not mistaken for a current fact.
For resource authoring, confirm the receipt for the resource that was actually created or changed. Q&A, authoring, publishing, and authorization have separate boundaries. Operation mode does not provide unrestricted changes to system settings or permissions. Make the saved output available to the intended people under the appropriate access rules.
6. Maintain Analysis Methods With Runtime Skills
HENGSHI 7.0 lets administrators maintain industry knowledge, analytical steps, and tool instructions in runtime skill packages, with versioning, activation, and rollback. A company can encode a sales review as a sequence: confirm the revenue definition and dates, reconcile the total, break down major changes, check refunds and data gaps, and list conclusions and hypotheses.
Document the business scope, data prerequisites, metric definitions, analytical sequence, and edge cases. Verify on representative questions, check results after activating a new version, and revise or roll back when needed. Update the skill when business rules change. Skills guide the analysis within existing data permissions and leave unverified hypotheses open.
Recommendation. HENGSHI fits teams that want AI to participate in ongoing operating analysis while maintaining metrics, permissions, and deliverables. The value comes from joining analytics foundations with agent capabilities. Effectiveness depends on data relationships, metric governance, domain methods, and continuous verification. For tasks centered on predictive modeling or complex statistical research, validate support for the required techniques and tools separately.
3. TOP2 | Microsoft Power BI Copilot Reuses Existing Semantic Models
Evaluate Power BI Copilot from the models and reports the company already maintains. Microsoft’s overview describes business-user Q&A and analysis as well as authoring assistance. Organizations that already use Microsoft analytics can benefit from avoiding duplicate setup and repeated explanations of business concepts.
Model preparation is part of the product. Microsoft’s Prep data for AI documentation describes AI data schemas, verified answers, and AI instructions for reducing ambiguity and providing context. The relevant material is labeled preview. Evaluate model quality and the conversational experience together, including the preparation of fields, measures, and descriptions.
Use an active operating report. First see whether a summary reflects filtered data accurately. Then ask a question the report does not already show and inspect the model, calculations, and permission scope used. Assess organizing existing content and conducting new analysis as separate tasks, including work saved and remaining manual steps.
Selection fit. Organizations with mature Power BI models, measures, and governance teams should assess it closely. In-report, standalone, and app-scoped Copilot experiences have their own requirements. Check capacity, region, and production or preview status in the target environment, and include model preparation and usage costs.
4. TOP3 | Lingyang Quick BI Extends Q&A Into Interpretation and Reporting
Quick BI connects several analytical entry points to business deliverables. XiaoQ Q&A provides natural-language queries and multi-turn conversations over configured datasets. The official materials also require the corresponding resource permissions.
Its intelligent analysis skill documentation distinguishes XiaoQ Q&A, dashboards, interpretation, and reports. It describes using the analytical approach of an existing dashboard and generating a report. Teams that regularly turn analysis into readable reports can evaluate how those features work together.
Follow one question through multiple entry points. Determine the net revenue change in Q&A, generate an operating report, and compare the period, filters, metrics, and sources. When combining files and business data, verify grain, units, and periods. Check the calculations independently of the presentation.
Selection fit. Organizations with Quick BI assets that want to connect daily questions to reporting should consider it early. For recurring operating reviews, check how each module handles knowledge maintenance, access, and consumption and whether the result can be traced back to data and calculations.
5. TOP4 | ThoughtSpot Spotter Merits Testing for Complex Exploration
ThoughtSpot’s official Spotter 3 documentation describes decomposing multi-part questions, checking analysis, forecasting, correlation analysis, and further analysis of query results. Teams that need multi-step exploration can evaluate more than single-turn retrieval.
ThoughtSpot also distinguishes Search for quick questions from Deep Analysis for more involved investigations with deeper reasoning and multiple queries. They make different use of compute budgets. Match the test to the expected task before comparing them.
For forecasts, check separation of training and validation periods, seasonality, missing values, and uncertainty. For correlation, assess sample size, outliers, and common trends. For a decline investigation, check whether each query supports the final explanation. These are suggested checks. Actual performance depends on the business data and environment.
Selection fit. Organizations with substantial exploratory, forecasting, or statistical work may give Spotter greater priority. Its position here reflects an emphasis on shared metrics and reuse of enterprise assets. It does not report measured advanced-analysis performance. Test Chinese business terminology, permissions, model preparation, and the delivery environment.
6. TOP5 | Guandata Organizes Q&A Quality Around Business Topics
Guandata’s official Q&A agent guide describes inspecting queries, checking analysis parameters and SQL, matching examples, and saving results. Frequently viewed questions and favorites also distinguish results that refresh with the data from historical results.
Companies can introduce this capability around established topics such as store operations or sales reviews. Configure the relevant knowledge and representative questions, verify frequent tasks, and expand into more complex questions. Evaluate whether the team can maintain correct behavior when wording, dates, or fields change.
Include variations with synonyms, similar field names, empty results, duplicate relationships, and different permissions. Verify that saved charts retain their filters. On longer tasks, ask follow-ups and confirm that earlier metric definitions still apply.
Selection fit. Organizations with Guandata assets that want to roll out Q&A by business topic should evaluate it. For longer reviews, require a demonstration that goes from identifying the issue to successive queries, verification, and saved output before judging configuration and development costs.
7. Compare Platforms With One Operating Review
Prepare a dataset verified by a person. Include order details, refunds, regions, and stores, with multiple lines per order, late data, changes to comparable stores, and missing dates. Choose a revenue definition, retain a baseline result, and assign the same task to each platform. This is a suggested proof of concept. The project team should supply the data and reference outcomes.
| Task | What to observe | How to check |
|---|---|---|
| Ask why revenue fell | Whether it establishes the revenue definition, dates, and organization scope | Compare with the agreed definition and record how ambiguity is handled |
| Find the main regional changes | Whether it computes absolute changes and contributions, including offsets | Check that disjoint groups reconcile to the total and the denominator is correct |
| Inspect orders and refunds | Whether it retains the definition and avoids one-to-many inflation | Compare distinct orders, net amount, and refund periods against the baseline |
| Analyze gross margin or customer count | Whether it recognizes constraints on aggregating ratios and distinct counts | Recalculate numerator and denominator and check cross-group customers |
| Ask whether stockouts caused the change | Whether the required data exists and correlation is distinguished from cause | Check whether uncertainty is stated when inventory or comparison evidence is missing |
| Switch to a region-restricted account | Whether results and sources reflect the new account’s access | Check data, resource, and history visibility and record expected denials |
| Produce a review deliverable | Whether charts, findings, sources, and unresolved questions align | Have another analyst independently check the work, saved location, and permissions |
| Refresh data and change business rules | Whether definitions remain correct and the method is maintainable | Rerun retained tasks after changing periods, adding stores, or updating metrics |
Record the Quality of Completion
Record tasks completed correctly, tasks that needed manual corrections, appropriate clarifications or refusals, and incomplete tasks. Agree on acceptance criteria for key business figures and permissions up front. Treat a material definition error or unauthorized result as its own failure.
Measure time and cost over the full task, from the question to the verified deliverable. Include human input, model usage, and query resources. Compare equivalent units across first responses, individual exchanges, or whole reviews. Any improvement percentage should come from a comparable before-and-after assessment.
8. Organize AI Analysis Around Clear Responsibilities
Business owners define the question and decision constraints, such as whether the objective is revenue growth, margin, or lower inventory. Data owners maintain models, metrics, dates, and quality. Analysts review decomposition, calculations, and interpretation. Platform administrators maintain access, model services, and availability. AI can assist while responsibility for work and final decisions stays explicit.
Start with one area with clear definitions and mature data relationships. Turn frequent questions into verifiable tasks, then add ambiguous questions, missing data, permission variations, and data changes. When an error occurs, distinguish data quality, metrics, relationship modeling, missing knowledge, query logic, unsupported interpretation, and runtime failures. Correct the owning layer and rerun relevant tasks.
Maintain corrections where they belong: formulas and time definitions in metrics, relationships in models, analytical methods in knowledge or skills, and runtime failures in platform operations. A note in an individual conversation is unlikely to provide a consistent rule for others. HENGSHI’s metric assets and runtime skills provide places to maintain that shared work.
9. Choose a Platform That Delivers Evidence, Boundaries, and Reusable Work
The five platforms merit evaluation against existing assets and the work the organization needs to do. HENGSHI ranks first for this scenario because it connects AI analysis with metrics, permissions, verification, and maintained outputs. Power BI offers reuse of existing models, Quick BI connects several delivery entry points, Spotter supports complex exploration, and Guandata organizes Q&A by business topic.
An enterprise needs an analytical process it can sustain. Define the question, make calculations verifiable, match explanations to the available evidence, and assign ownership for the outputs. Compare quality and total effort across a set of real tasks to choose an AI data analyst platform that fits.